Table 3 RIGHT Statement and AGREE Reporting Checklist domains and essential items [47, 49]
RIGHT Statement (2017) | AGREE reporting Checklist (2016) |
|---|---|
Basic information | Domain 1. Scope and Purpose |
1. Title/subtitle | 1. Objectives |
2. Executive summary | 2. Questions |
3. Abbreviations and acronyms | 3. Population |
4. Corresponding developer | Domain 2. Stakeholder Involvement |
Background | 4. Group membership |
5. Description of the health problem(s) | 5. Target population preferences and views |
6. Aim(s) of the guideline and objectives | 6. Target users |
7. Target population(s) | Domain 3. Rigour of Development |
8. End users and settings | 7. Search methods |
9. Guideline development groups | 8. Evidence selection criteria |
Evidence | 9. Strengths and limitations of the evidence |
10. Health care questions | 10. Formulation of recommendations |
11. Systematic reviews | 11. Consideration of benefits and harms |
12. Assessment of the certainty of the body of evidence | 12. Link between recommendations and evidence |
Recommendations | 13. External review |
13. Recommendations | 14. Updating procedure |
14. Rationale for recommendations | Domain 4. Clarity of Presentation |
15. Evidence to decision processes | 15. Specific and unambiguous recommendations |
Review and quality assurance | 16. Management options |
16. External review | 17. Identifiable key recommendations |
17. Quality assurance | Domain 5. Applicability |
Funding and declaration of interests | 18. Facilitators and barriers |
18. Funding source(s) and role(s) of the funder | 19. Implementation advice/tools |
19. Declaration and management of interests | 20. Resource implications |
Other information | 21. Monitoring/ auditing criteria |
20. Access | Domain 6. Editorial Independence |
21. Suggestions for further research | 22. Funding body |
22. Limitations of the guideline | 23. Competing interests |